The order below is the order a funder's staff actually work. A file that fails at point one is never seen at point six.
1. Registration and legal status.
What fails. The applicant is not registered where the funder requires, or cannot prove what it is. For any federal dollar, including money that passes through Kentucky or Louisville Metro, that means an active SAM.gov registration and a Unique Entity Identifier. The National Park Service notice, Kentucky Humanities, FEMA's security grant, Metro's block grant, and both earmark paths all require it, and Grants.gov will not accept a submission without it. For private funders it means the IRS determination letter, a current W-9, and proof of good standing. Metro's Neighborhood Development Fund and External Agency Fund also require good standing with the Kentucky Secretary of State, the Metro Revenue Commission and the Metro Human Relations Commission. The two small National Trust funds require organizational membership in the Trust's Preservation Leadership Forum before funds are released, not before applying; the church can file both on October 1 without it. Kentucky Humanities is the one case where the registration gate is later than it looks: its September 30 date is a letter of intent, and SAM.gov must be active by the October 31 full application; the real gate there is the humanities scholar who must have agreed to serve.
How often. This is the most common way a small organization's first federal application dies, and it dies quietly: the portal refuses the file, or the registration is still pending on deadline day. SAM.gov takes weeks, and longer when a name or address on the IRS record does not match the state record exactly. Private funders are more forgiving, but a missing IRS letter or W-9 makes a file incomplete, and the Kentucky African American Heritage Commission's form states plainly that incomplete applications are the one thing it excludes.
What passing looks like here. The church already has its legal status: EIN 61-0730354, 501(c)(3), listed in IRS Publication 78 (Section 5.2). Three gaps remain. The church has no SAM.gov registration; start it the week this report is read, assign one person to own the login, and put the annual renewal on the calendar. The IRS determination letter is dated 2025, which will prompt "how long have you existed?" from any funder with an age rule; the answer is the congregation's 1833 organization and its long-standing exemption as a church, and the church should keep a one-paragraph explanation with the letter. And no one has yet opened the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search in a browser and saved a screenshot of the church's listing (Section 5.8, item U1); do that once and keep it in the grant file.
2. Eligibility rules: the parcel, religious use, age of organization, and level of significance.
What fails. The applicant or the property is outside the rule. Four rules matter for this church.
The parcel. Preservation funders fund a specific property, and they check that the applicant owns it and that the listed building sits on the parcel named. The county record shows the church as owner of the school parcel and ties the National Register listing to that parcel (Section 5.5). But the deed itself, showing when and from whom the church acquired the school, has not been produced (Section 5.8, item U2), and the National Trust programs ask for the recorded instrument at application. The parcel is also why the school cannot go into the Preserving Black Churches program: that program funds auxiliary buildings only "on the same lot and within the property line of the church," and the school is on its own parcel about 660 feet from the sanctuary (Section 2.9).
Religious use. Federal money cannot pay for a sanctuary or any room used as a principal place of worship (24 CFR 5.109, cited in the Metro block grant entry in Part A), and it can pay for a church-owned building only for its secular use. Lowe's, The Home Depot Foundation, U.S. Bank, PNC, Bank of America, State Farm, the James Graham Brown Foundation and the Kentucky Colonels each admit a church only when the funded space or program is open to everyone without a religious condition. Metro's own rule bars Neighborhood Development Fund money from capital improvements to any faith-based organization's property.
Age of organization. The Kentucky Colonels require five years of existence; The Home Depot Foundation requires one. A funder reading the 2025 IRS letter alone would fail the church on the first.
Level of significance. Save America's Treasures requires national significance or National Historic Landmark status; the school's listing is at the Jefferson County level (Section 5.3), so that program is closed for good and the report says so. The Action Fund and Preserving Black Churches require that the building be at least 50 years old; the school passes, and the sanctuary's date is not yet documented (Section 5.8, item U12).
How often. Eligibility errors are the most common reason a well-written application is declined without comment, and they are easy to make even for professionals. The strategy memo that started this research assumed Metro's Neighborhood Development Fund could pay for capital work on church property, and quoted an Action Fund ceiling of $500,000 that belongs to a different program; both were corrected by reading the rule at its source. A church that applies to a program it is ineligible for loses more than one application, because the same reviewers see the next one.
What passing looks like here. The recorded deed, pulled from the Jefferson County Clerk's deed index. A two-page community-use plan for the school that states, in the funder's own terms, that the building serves the whole public without regard to religion, with the programs named. A board-adopted non-discrimination policy. A one-paragraph organizational history with the 1833 date and the church's prior status as a tax-exempt church. The sanctuary's construction date with a source. And discipline about which door to knock on: the school goes to the school programs, the sanctuary goes to the church programs, and neither is argued into the other.
3. Required attachments.
What fails. A named attachment is missing, or is not what the funder asked for. The attachments the top ten sources name are: proof of ownership; the IRS determination letter; a W-9 on the current form; current photographs; the National Register listing name and reference; a map or site plan; letters of consent from all owners of the property (the Kentucky African American Heritage Commission asks for this even when the applicant is the owner); a cost estimate or contractor quote; an architect's quote for planning grants; letters of support or commitment; a board list; financial statements; and, for federal applications, the forms generated inside Grants.gov. The Kentucky Colonels require a letter of intent before the portal will even open. Several funders ask for a Form 990, which a church does not file; the church must say so in writing rather than leave the field blank.
How often. Often enough that most funders' first screening step is a checklist. A file missing one attachment is marked incomplete and, at most programs, is not returned for correction; the applicant waits a year.
What passing looks like here. A single grant file, kept in one place, containing every item in Section 3.2 in its current version, so that any application can be assembled by copying from it. Today the church can produce the legal documents and the National Register and Fisk records in an afternoon. It cannot yet produce photographs, a condition statement, a cost estimate, or the deed. Those are the four attachments to build first.
4. The scope, the cost estimate, and the conditions assessment.
What fails. The application asks for money to "renovate the school." Funders do not fund intentions; they fund a described piece of work with a price attached, prepared by someone qualified to price it. A conditions assessment is a professional's written survey of what is wrong with the building and what it will take to fix it. A scope of work is the list of the specific work to be done. A cost estimate prices that scope. For a National Register building, all three must be written to the Secretary of the Interior's Standards, which are the federal rules for repairing historic buildings so that their historic features are kept, and the person preparing them should have historic rehabilitation experience. The National Park Service, the Action Fund, the Kentucky Heritage Council, Lowe's, the Kentucky Colonels, Republic Bank and the Bruckheimer Fund all want a bounded, priced item. The Action Fund's rules exclude any expense incurred before the award, so the scope must also be work that has not started.
How often. This is the gate that separates "interested" from "fundable," and it is where most first-time building owners stall, usually for the understandable reason that they are waiting for a grant to pay for the assessment. The report is built around not letting that happen: the assessment is prerequisite five in Section 2.2, and the recommended sequence is planning first, capital second.
What passing looks like here. Two quotes for a conditions assessment in October, from an architect or contractor with historic rehabilitation experience; the assessment commissioned in November and delivered with a cost estimate by mid-January 2027; and the estimate broken into phases (for example, roof and envelope; windows and structure; interior and systems) so that each funder can be asked for one phase at a price its program allows. If the church cannot pay for the assessment itself this fall, the fallback is a Project Planning request to the Action Fund in February, which is a legitimate application with better odds than a capital request without an estimate (Section 2.8).
5. Match and cash-flow capacity.
What fails. The applicant promises a match it has not secured, or accepts a grant it cannot float. Several sources in this report require match: the National Fund for Sacred Places requires a dollar-for-dollar cash match raised after acceptance, with a quarter of it in hand before the first payment; the Daughters of the American Revolution require dollar-for-dollar secured cash; Preservation Kentucky requires dollar-for-dollar cash; Kentucky Humanities requires dollar-for-dollar cash or in-kind; the Kentucky Heritage Council's Certified Local Government grant requires a 40 percent local share. Separately, many awards reimburse rather than pay in advance: the Kentucky Colonels require all purchases complete and receipts submitted by October 30 of the award year; federal and Metro awards reimburse after the church has paid; the Neighborhood Development Fund wants receipts and cancelled checks within 60 days. Federal construction money above $2,000 also brings prevailing-wage rules (Davis-Bacon), which raise the price of labor, and federal spending above $1,000,000 in a year triggers a single audit.
How often. Match failures show up after award, which is the worst time: the funder's staff ask for the match documentation before releasing money, and a "pledge" that was really a hope cannot be produced. Cash-flow failures are quieter and more damaging. A small organization wins a reimbursement grant, starts work, cannot pay the contractor while waiting for reimbursement, and either stops work or borrows against the building. The strategy memo flagged this as the failure most likely to hurt a church of this size, and the research has not seen the church's cash position.
What passing looks like here. Before any application is filed, the treasurer writes one number for the board: the amount the church can pay out and wait 90 days to get back. Every ask is sized to that number, or paired with a bridge (the Vital Sites loan fund in Part C exists for this). Match is documented, not described: written pledges for cash, and for in-kind, a letter from the donor stating the fair market value of materials or labor. Corporate in-kind commitments (Lowe's, Home Depot, GAF, paint) become match for foundation and federal asks only when that letter exists. One rule to remember: National Trust money cannot be used as match for another National Trust program.
6. The narrative and the outcome claims.
What fails. The story cannot be checked, or the numbers cannot be proven. Reviewers of heritage applications read hundreds of "historic and beloved" buildings; what they trust is a specific claim with a source. This building's story has already been through that test in Section 5, and some of what circulates about it is wrong: the church did not buy the school in 1979 (private owners did), the school did not have six teachers (it was built to a six-teacher plan and ran with about three), and the architect was Oscar W. Holmes, not Moore Brothers. An application that repeats the wrong version, read by a reviewer who has the nomination open in another window, is a lost application. Outcome claims fail the same way. "The restored school will strengthen the community" cannot be scored. "The school will be open 20 hours a week and host a senior program on Tuesdays and Thursdays, a youth history program in summer, and an annual alumni reunion, all open to the public" can be, and it can be checked a year later.
How often. Constantly, and usually not fatally on its own, because a weak narrative lowers a score rather than eliminating a file. It becomes fatal in combination: a file with no assessment, no use plan, and a story built on legend reads as a hope, not a project, and hopes do not get funded at $150,000.
What passing looks like here. The narrative uses only the facts in Section 5, cites the National Register nomination and the Fisk card, and states the one claim that no other applicant can make: as far as can be determined, this is the only surviving elementary school built for Black students in Jefferson County outside the city of Louisville, one of three surviving Rosenwald schools of the seven the county built. The community-use plan supplies the outcomes as counts: hours open, programs, people served, and who will run them. The tone is stewardship, not rescue. The congregation that owns this building has kept it standing, and the application should say so plainly rather than describe the building only by its damage.
7. Budget-to-narrative reconciliation.
What fails. The budget and the narrative describe different projects, or the budget asks a funder for something its rules exclude. Every program in this report has rules about what its money may touch. The Action Fund excludes acquisition, new construction, and expenses before the award. The National Trust Preservation Funds pay for planning only, never bricks; the Bruckheimer Fund pays for bricks. The Kentucky Colonels exclude salaries, marketing, design fees, and improvements to leased property. Metro's Neighborhood Development Fund excludes indirect costs and sales tax. The National Endowment for the Humanities does not fund construction. The James Graham Brown Foundation's minimum grant is $150,000; the National Fund for Sacred Places caps planning at $20,000. A budget that asks a planning fund for a roof, or a bricks fund for a consultant, or that includes work already begun, fails on arithmetic before anyone reads the prose.
How often. In practice, budgets and narratives are written by different people and reconciled by no one, and reviewers are trained to check. The tell is a budget line that funds no described activity, or a described activity with no line.
What passing looks like here. One master cost estimate for the school, from the conditions assessment, broken into phases and line items. Each application takes a slice of it that matches that funder's allowable costs, and the narrative describes exactly that slice. No cost appears in two applications for the same dollars. Where two funders will pay for parts of the same phase, the budget shows each funder's share on separate lines. Someone other than the person who wrote the narrative reads the budget against it before filing.
8. Compliance formalities: page limits, formats, and the deadline in the funder's time zone.
What fails. The file is late, over length, in the wrong format, or submitted in the wrong place. Deadlines in this report carry times, not just dates: the Action Fund closed at 5 pm Eastern; Preserving Black Churches closed at 5 pm Eastern; the National Fund for Sacred Places closes at 11:59 pm Eastern. Louisville is on Eastern time, so the church shares a clock with these funders, but "5 pm" is not "end of day," and a portal that receives a file at 5:01 pm records it as late. Federal notices post with windows of about 30 days and the National Park Service's next round will likely be no different (Section 2.9); Grants.gov submissions also fail for technical reasons that take a day to fix, so a federal file submitted on deadline day is a gamble. Several portals require accounts that must be created and approved in advance: Foundant for the National Trust, the Sacred Places fund, Kentucky Humanities and the Kentucky Colonels; Euna Grants for Metro; SmartSimple for Humana.
How often. Late and non-compliant files are rejected without review at nearly every program that runs a formal round, and no one calls to warn the applicant. It is the least forgivable failure because it is entirely within the applicant's control.
What passing looks like here. One person owns the calendar in Section 2.7 and the accounts in Section 11.3, and every application is submitted at least two working days before its deadline. Each application is checked against the funder's own instructions, including page limits, file types, and naming rules, by someone who did not write it. Portal accounts are created in the fall, not in the week of a deadline.
Once a file clears the gates, it goes to a review panel. At the programs that matter most here, the readers are preservation professionals scoring against the funder's published criteria, and they read many files in a short time. Five things decide the score for a building like this one, and each has a common way of losing points.
The significance story. The reviewer wants to know, in the first page, why this building and not another. The strongest version is specific and sourced: a brick Rosenwald school built in 1929 to 1930 when most were frame, on a six-teacher plan, designed by Oscar W. Holmes, with $200 raised by the Black community of Jeffersontown alongside the Rosenwald grant and public funds; the only surviving elementary school built for Black students in Jefferson County outside the city of Louisville, as far as the 1984 nomination could determine; one of three surviving Rosenwald schools of the seven the county built; individually listed on the National Register in 1985; closed at integration in 1961; now owned by a congregation organized in 1833 that worships two blocks away and has been on that site since 1877. Where files like this lose points: legend in place of record (the 1979 purchase, the six teachers), a name that shifts between "Alexander-Ingram" and "Jeffersontown Colored School" without explanation (use the National Register name once, then the local name, and say they are the same building), and significance asserted without the National Register reference number. The nomination is the reviewer's source; make it the church's.
The community-use case. Preservation funders no longer fund buildings to be kept; they fund buildings to be used, and both the Action Fund and the National Park Service weigh community benefit. The reviewer is looking for named programs, named partners, hours, and numbers, and for evidence that the community asked for this rather than being told about it. Where files lose points: "community center" with no programs named; a use plan that is really a wish; letters of support from organizations that will do nothing. Passing here is the two-page use plan with programs, a partner (the Greater Jeffersontown Historical Society, a school, a senior program) who has agreed in writing to run something in the building, and the city's resolution. The church's own history helps: a congregation that has been in the same neighborhood since 1877 is the kind of steward reviewers believe will still be there in twenty years.
The commitment to preservation standards. Every federal and National Trust dollar in this report requires work to the Secretary of the Interior's Standards, which in plain terms means repair rather than replace, keep what is original, and make new work compatible and reversible. The reviewer looks for three signals: that the applicant names the Standards, that the professional preparing the scope has done this kind of work before, and that the scope treats the building's defining features with care. For this school those features are named in the nomination: brick walls with limestone trim, the recessed arched entrances with limestone voussoirs, the large industrial-type windows (boarded since at least 1984), the buttress-like pilasters, and a flat roof with a parapet on three sides. Where files lose points: replacement windows where repair was possible, a shingle roof on a flat-roofed building (the roofing entry in Part C already flags this), the word "modernize," and no mention of the Section 106 review that federal money triggers. Passing is a scope that says what will be repaired, what will be replaced and why, and a board that has already voted to accept a preservation covenant if one is required.
The sustainability plan. The reviewer asks what happens to the building after the grant. Where files lose points, more than anywhere else in the narrative: "we will pursue additional grant funding." That is not a plan; it is a description of the applicant's current activity. Passing names a mechanism: a line in the church's annual operating budget for the school's utilities, insurance and maintenance; income from community use of the building; program funding from sources that pay for programs (Metro's Neighborhood Development Fund and External Agency Fund, the Humana Foundation, the Kentucky African American Heritage Commission, Kentucky Humanities), which is exactly what those sources in this report are good for; the Kentucky historic rehabilitation tax credit as an offset once the revised rules land; and a named person or committee responsible for the building. A small, believable number beats a large, hopeful one.
The photographs. Reviewers look at the pictures before they read the text, and they look at them again while scoring the scope. They want to see the whole building, the damage that justifies the ask, and the historic fabric that justifies preserving it, in the same set. Where files lose points: a few exterior shots, no interiors, no roof, nothing dated, and nothing that shows the problem the budget says it will fix. Passing is the set described in Section 3.2: all four elevations, the roof, every room, the basement, the systems, close-ups of the damage, each one labeled with the date and the location, plus one of the two Fisk University photographs of the building when it was new so the reviewer can see what it was.
One last point, because it is the one that undoes everything above. A reviewer who finds an eligibility stretch on page one reads the rest of the file looking for the next one (Section 2.9). The church's strongest position is the honest one: the school to the school programs, the sanctuary to the church programs, every claim traceable to a record, every number to an estimate, and every promise to a document in the grant file.